EV Showdown 2025: Tata Punch EV vs. MG Comet vs. Mahindra XUV400

⚡ Introduction: India’s EV Boom Is Real in 2025

Electric cars are no longer the future — they're the present. With fuel prices soaring and urban buyers turning eco-conscious, affordable electric vehicles (EVs) are now the hottest segment in Indian auto.

In 2025, three names dominate this buzz: Tata Punch EV, MG Comet, and Mahindra XUV400. But which one should you buy?

We’ve compared the trio on price, range, features, and practicality to help you make a smart decision.

---

🚘 Quick Overview

Car	Starting Price (₹)	Range (Claimed)	Battery	Body Type
Tata Punch EV	₹10.99 – 14.49 Lakh	315–421 km	25–35 kWh	Compact SUV
MG Comet EV	₹6.98 – 8.58 Lakh	230 km	17.3 kWh	Micro Hatch
Mahindra XUV400	₹15.49 – 17.49 Lakh	375–456 km	34.5–39.4 kWh	Sub-4m SUV

---

⚙️ 1. Battery & Range: Who Goes the Distance?

• Tata Punch EV comes with two variants: Medium Range (315 km) and Long Range (421 km). Suitable for both city and light intercity runs.

• MG Comet EV is strictly city-focused with a smaller 230 km range.

• Mahindra XUV400 leads the range battle with up to 456 km, ideal for highway and daily long commutes.

Verdict: For range, XUV400 > Punch EV > MG Comet

---

🎯 2. Price & Affordability

• MG Comet EV is the most affordable, great for first-time buyers or second-car households.

• Tata Punch EV sits in the sweet spot: budget-friendly yet packed with SUV DNA.

• Mahindra XUV400 is pricier, but justifiable for its longer range and stronger motor.

Verdict: Budget-conscious = MG Comet | Balanced = Punch EV

---

💡 3. Features & Tech

• Tata Punch EV: 10.25" touchscreen, connected tech, 360° camera, ventilated seats (top variant) – feels premium.

• MG Comet: Smart tech with dual screens, voice commands, but lacks in size and practicality.

• XUV400: Larger infotainment, sunroof, and safety-rich, but dated interiors vs Punch.

Verdict: Punch EV wins on features + tech at value.

---

🛡️ 4. Safety & Build

• Tata Punch EV & XUV400 both expected to score well in crash safety (ICE counterparts already 5-star GNCAP rated).

• MG Comet is compact and built for city use, not ideal for highways.

Verdict: Long-term safety = Punch EV and XUV400

---

🌆 5. City Drive or Highway Utility?

• MG Comet: Best for city zipping, tight spaces, easy parking

• Punch EV: Great for urban + occasional highway

• XUV400: Ideal for highway riders, intercity travel

---

🔋 Charging & Service Network

• Tata and Mahindra have wider EV infrastructure and after-sales networks.

• MG is improving but still limited to urban India.

---

🏁 Final Verdict: Which EV Should You Choose in 2025?

• Want a budget city car? → Go for the MG Comet EV

• Need a value-packed electric SUV with tech & comfort? → Choose the Tata Punch EV

• Craving long range + highway-ready power? → Bet on the Mahindra XUV400

---

✨ Pro Tip:

If you’re planning a first-time EV buy in 2025, Punch EV’s balance of price, features, and practicality makes it a top recommendation for most Indian users.